The Best Toasters for Even, Golden Toast

We Review the Best Toaster Ovens

A toaster has one job, and many still do it badly: pale on one side, burnt on the other, and different every morning. The good ones toast evenly, handle thick bagels and remember how you like it.

Quick answer: the Cuisinart 2-Slice Digital Toaster with MemorySet is our best overall pick. For a family, the KRUPS Breakfast Set 4-Slice Toaster toasts four slices evenly. If you want a toaster that lowers and lifts itself, the Breville Die-Cast Smart Toaster is worth the upgrade. Want a toaster oven instead? See our toaster oven guide.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This post contains affiliate links.

Our Top Picks at a Glance

Top pick

Cuisinart 2-Slice Digital Toaster with MemorySet (representative image)
Representative image

Cuisinart 2-Slice Digital Toaster with MemorySet

For home cooks who want breakfast toast to come out the same way every time, this Cuisinart makes it easy to match the setting to your bread. Its even browning, bread-specific presets, and MemorySet button help take the guesswork out of busy mornings.

  • Even browning every morning
  • Preset settings for breads
  • MemorySet saves your favorite

Check price on Amazon →

Best 4-slice toaster: KRUPS Breakfast Set 4-Slice Toaster

Two independent sides with even browning, ideal for busy family breakfasts.

Check price →

Which Toaster Is Right for You? You want consistent toast, every morning: Cuisinart 2-Slice MemorySet; You toast for a family of four or more: KRUPS Breakfast Set 4-Slice; You want precise control and a premium build: Breville Die-Cast Smart Toaster; You just need reliable toast, cheap: Hamilton Beach 2-Slice; Your toaster lives on display: Smeg 50's Retro

How we chose: we focused on models that are in production now, do well in recent hands-on reviews from kitchen testers and have a long track record with owners. We do not list prices or star ratings because both change constantly.

The Best Toasters, Reviewed

1. Cuisinart 2-Slice Digital Toaster with MemorySet

Best overall. This Cuisinart has presets for white, whole grain, waffles, bagels and more, plus a countdown display so you know exactly when toast is coming up. The MemorySet button saves your favorite setting.

  • Good for: Households with different bread preferences and anyone who wants consistent toast.
  • Keep in mind: More buttons than a basic toaster, which some people find fussy.

Check the Cuisinart CPT-720 on Amazon →

2. Breville Die-Cast Smart Toaster

Best smart toaster. Press a button and the Breville lowers the bread for you, then raises it gently when done. ‘Lift and Look’ lets you check progress without stopping the cycle, and ‘A bit more’ adds a short extra burst.

  • Good for: Anyone who wants precise control and a toaster built to last.
  • Keep in mind: Expensive for a 2-slice toaster.

Check the Breville Die-Cast Smart Toaster on Amazon →

3. KRUPS Breakfast Set 4-Slice Toaster

Best 4-slice toaster. Four wide slots with separate controls for each pair, so one person can toast bagels while another makes light toast. It browns evenly and the exterior stays fairly cool.

  • Good for: Families and anyone who makes toast for more than two people.
  • Keep in mind: It takes up more counter space than a 2-slice model and has no countdown display.

Check the KRUPS 4-Slice on Amazon →

4. Hamilton Beach 2-Slice Extra-Wide Slot Toaster

Best budget pick. Hamilton Beach’s basic 2-slice toasters do the essentials well for very little money: wide slots, bagel and defrost settings, and a removable crumb tray.

  • Good for: Dorms, first apartments and anyone who just wants reliable toast.
  • Keep in mind: Basic build and no extras like a countdown or motorized lift.

Check the Hamilton Beach 2-Slice on Amazon →

5. Smeg 50's Retro Style 2-Slice Toaster

Best-looking toaster. If your toaster lives on the counter full-time, Smeg’s rounded retro design and color options make it a kitchen centerpiece. It toasts evenly and includes reheat, defrost and bagel settings.

  • Good for: Design-focused kitchens and gifts.
  • Keep in mind: You pay mostly for the looks; there are no smart features.

Check the Smeg Retro Toaster on Amazon →

6. Cuisinart Metal Classic 4-Slice Toaster

Best classic 4-slice. The Metal Classic has been a solid choice for years. Each pair of slots has its own controls, with bagel, defrost and reheat buttons and a polished stainless body.

  • Good for: Families who want a simple, durable 4-slice toaster.
  • Keep in mind: Slots are standard width, so very thick artisan bread may not fit.

Check the Cuisinart CPT-180 on Amazon →

Related reading: Best Slow Cookers for Set-It-and-Forget-It Meals and Instant Pot Viva vs Duo

Also great

Best smart toaster: Breville Die-Cast Smart Toaster (representative image)
Representative image

Best smart toaster: Breville Die-Cast Smart Toaster

For home cooks who want toast that feels a little more polished, the Breville Die-Cast Smart Toaster makes breakfast easier and more consistent. Its motorized lift, Lift and Look, and A bit more controls help you check browning and fine-tune the finish without fuss.

  • Hands-free lowering and lifting
  • Check progress without stopping
  • Fine-tune toast to taste

Check price on Amazon →

Quick Comparison

ModelBest forStandout feature
Cuisinart CPT-720Best overallBread presets and MemorySet
Breville Die-Cast Smart ToasterBest smart toasterMotorized lift, Lift and Look
KRUPS 4-SliceBest 4-slice toasterTwo independently controlled sides
Hamilton Beach 2-SliceBest budget pickExtra-wide slots, low price
Smeg Retro ToasterBest-looking toasterRetro design, many colors
Cuisinart CPT-180Best classic 4-sliceDual controls, stainless body

How to Choose a Toaster

2-slice or 4-slice

Two slices suit one or two people and save space. Four slices (or two long slots) speed up family breakfasts. Long-slot toasters fit sourdough and rye loaves better.

Slot width

Wide slots (about 1.5 inches) take bagels, thick bread and frozen waffles. Self-centering guides help thick and thin slices toast evenly.

Useful settings

A bagel setting toasts the cut side more than the crust. Defrost adds time for frozen bread. Reheat warms toast without browning it further. A countdown timer is a nice extra.

Cleaning and safety

A slide-out crumb tray is a must. Cool-touch exteriors and automatic shut-off add safety. Never dig out stuck bread with a metal utensil while the toaster is plugged in.

FAQ

Why does my toaster toast unevenly?

Uneven heating elements, crumbs blocking the elements or slices of different thickness. Empty the crumb tray, and try toasting one slice in the center of a slot to compare.

How often should I clean a toaster?

Empty the crumb tray weekly. Unplug and shake out loose crumbs every month or so.

Is a toaster oven better than a toaster?

For plain toast, a toaster is faster and more even. A toaster oven is more versatile if you also bake and reheat.

Keep reading:

Tags:

Share:

Related Post